serving the freshest beats since 2001

making haterade out of haters, one glass at a time

idiotic decisions by the religious right

As a scientist by training, it pains me when I see full-on idiocy being promoted by anyone, but of late, it's largely been the conservatives with their heads up their asses. The latest offense is the effort in promoting the teaching of "intelligent design" (read: creationism) in schools. This one galls me the most because I am a biologist. Sure, I suppose an omnipotent higher power could have designed all life on this planet, and embedded fossils in the ground, but by the same token, a highly advanced race of space aliens could have done the same thing. That doesn't mean that it happened. Evolution is the simplest explanation - we've actually seen evolution at work in the adaptation of various microbes to selective pressures. Occam's Razor applies here, folks - that's kind of the whole point of science. Science is about finding facts, and then developing the simplest theory that encompasses the totality of the facts. Inventing a higher power or an alien race is quite clearly not the simplest theory when we already have observed evolutionary events occur (albeit not on a grand scale).

From a recent article in the Washington Post:

At the state and local level, from South Carolina to California, these advocates are using lawsuits and school board debates to counter evolutionary theory. Alabama and Georgia legislators recently introduced bills to allow teachers to challenge evolutionary theory in the classroom. Ohio, Minnesota, New Mexico and Ohio have approved new rules allowing that. And a school board member in a Tennessee county wants stickers pasted on textbooks that say evolution remains unproven.

A prominent effort is underway in Kansas, where the state Board of Education intends to revise teaching standards. That would be progress, Southern Baptist minister Terry Fox said, because "most people in Kansas don't think we came from monkeys."

Of course evolution remains unproven. You can never prove a theory beyond a doubt, as it only takes one counter-example to disprove it. However, evolution has withstood all challenges to this date, and my guess is that it will continue to do so. And with (no) respect to the minister - evolution doesn't say that we came from monkeys, it says that at some point long ago in the past, it is likely that we shared a common ancestor. There is a significant difference in meaning.

Go read the rest of the article. It's not just limited to evolution, but that's the visible issue. The religious right is systematically dismantling scientific thought and replacing it with their own beliefs. It's terribly depressing that most Americans can't separate their faith from their worldview. It's one of the reasons that the U.S. is falling behind Europe, Japan, and soon China and India in innovation, research, productivity, you name it. Better go learn Mandarin soon.

« server downtime | Main | playlist [15 March 2005] »
Comments

I don't understand why it has to be one or the other. Why can't we accept the theory of evolution, while believing that god is still overseeing everything and made it possible for it all to happen? Anyhoo, that's how I see things. Something tells me that one side would be a bit more willing to agree with that than the other...

I'm really disgusted by all these religious fucks who want to eliminate science from the schools. Someething tells me after they eat one pork rind too many and have their third heart attack, they'll be all in favor of science digging into their chests and getting things working again. That's why I respect Christian Scientists; at least they're honest about their beliefs.

I'm not saying that one can't have one's beliefs. But belief shouldn't be taught in public school - that goes back to the fundamental principle of the separation of church and state. If you accept the theory of evolution, but feel that it must have been guided by the Hand of God, well, fine. But we shouldn't be teaching that, as there is no concrete evidence to suggest that there is a Hand of God that guided evolution. Again, it boils down to Occam's Razor. As far as I can tell, we will never be able to devise an experiment that proves (or disproves) the existence of God. Therefore, there is no scientific theory that can allow for God to exist. Only belief/faith can allow for God to exist. I have no objection to that. I do have an objection to imposing faith on people (as they want to do by teaching the so-called "intelligent design" theory).

Oh I agree with you...I wasn't really thinking about school specifically, but about society's views in general, and how people seem to look at this argument in a very binary way. But you are correct, schools should not be promoting religion.

Post a comment




Remember Me?

(you may use HTML tags for style)

Site navigation